• Skip to primary navigation
  • Skip to main content
  • Skip to primary sidebar
  • Skip to footer
  • Home
  • About
  • Contact
  • Partner with Taryn

Taryn Whiteaker Designs

DIY and Interior Blog

  • Our Dallas Home Tour
  • Shop My Pics
  • Home Styling
    • Room Reveals
      • Our Current Home
      • Our First Home
    • Seasonal Home Tours
  • DIY Projects
    • DIY Home Decor
    • Crafts & Sewing
    • Before and Afters
    • Before and Afters
    • Furniture Builds and Makeovers
  • Seasonal Decor
    • Christmas
    • Easter
    • Fall
    • Fourth of July
    • Halloween
    • Spring
    • Valentine’s Day
  • Printables
  • Entertaining
    • Parties
    • Tablescapes
  • Fashion
  • Travel

September 20, 2020

Stone Fireplace Makeover

Alright guys! It’s the final, part 3 of the fireplace makeover! And this time it’s done and I LOVE it! It finally feels like I wanted it to for our space. So let’s dive right into our stone fireplace makeover and how we got here.

Stone Fireplace Makeover

Take your dark stone fireplace and turn it into something more modern and chic with this stone fireplace makeover on a budget!

In case you missed the previous versions, here is part 1 where I did a white wash stone and part 2 when I did the German Schmear. I didn’t love it at either stage, but I wanted to show you all my process. I put the final touches on everything with the new mantel and I feel like it finally fits our home!

Before Mantel

In case you need a refresh, here is what it looked like exactly one year ago! The stone is great, but it was very dark for our home. We have also added hardwoods in since then!

German Schmear Stone Fireplace

I am really loving the off white German schmear with the light wood mantel and the bold black accents. I feel like it goes SO much better with our kitchen remodel and the new hardwoods.

Raw Wood Mantel

Take your dark stone fireplace and turn it into something more modern and chic with this stone fireplace makeover on a budget!

Since our downstairs is one big open space, I wanted the wood tone of the mantel to blend with our kitchen accents. So I ended up using the exact same open shelving from the kitchen, but this time picked the plain version versus the ones with the black straps. I ended up cutting off the capped ends and converting them into the perfect solution to fit right over our existing mantel. It was an extremely easy project (much easier than I expected!). And I didn’t have to rip out our old one.

I have gotten a lot of requests for a full tutorial on how to make this mantel, so I will be doing a tutorial for you soon!

The brand I purchased for the mantel actually makes metal beam straps, but they ended up not being deep enough for our mantel (they are made for their beams, and I am using the shelves). Anyway, in my search for the perfect solution, I found this rubber faux beam strap on Amazon. It’s made to look like metal, but it gives you the flexibility to bend it over any size beam. You simply adhere it with industrial adhesive and a few finishing nails.

Fall Mantel Accessories

To finish it off, I styled it with this cute modern firewood holder. Ok, I know we have a gas fireplace, but I love the look of firewood!

Take your dark stone fireplace and turn it into something more modern and chic with this stone fireplace makeover on a budget!

I also added these cute copper lanterns with some wheat grass.

Take your dark stone fireplace and turn it into something more modern and chic with this stone fireplace makeover on a budget!

If you are a visual person, here is a video showing this part of the process!

I’ve gotten quite a few negative comments on Instagram about this makeover. Here is the deal, I liked our fireplace before and I like it now, they are just two totally different looks and what it came down to for me is that the dark brown stone just didn’t fit into the style of our downstairs. It was too ‘heavy’, it really weighed down the corner of the living and my goal was to make it feel less of a focal point and more of a ‘cozy accent corner’.

At the end of the day, you have to think about the space as a whole, versus the individual fireplace. And I finally feel like it’s the right fit for our house for right now. It was a relatively inexpensive fix, but maybe one day we will take it down and do something completely new.

SHOP THS SPACE

Other Posts You May Like:

White Wash Brick Tutorial

German Schmear Stone Fireplace Tutorial

Faux Beam Mantel Tutorial

About Taryn Whiteaker

Hi! I’m Taryn! The voice behind Taryn Whiteaker Designs. I launched this brand over 11 years ago when I became a stay-at-home mom. What started as a small craft and mom blog eventually grew into a full time design and DIY site. My goal has always been to inspire others (especially women!) with design ideas, DIY tutorials, entertaining ideas and give you the tools you need to complete them yourself!

You May Also Like:

  • TarynWhiteakerDesigns_OutdoorFireplaceChristmas-16
    Outdoor Fireplace Christmas Decor
  • Modern French Country Balcony Decor-10
    Modern French Country Balcony Makeover
  • Coyote Outdoor Appliances-2
    Stone Outdoor Kitchen Design
  • Brick Fireplace Decor-7
    Modern English Brick Fireplace Decor
  • Modern European Outdoor Fireplace Seating Area-4
    Modern European Outdoor Fireplace Seating Area

Filed Under: ALL POSTS

Reader Interactions

Comments

  1. Tammy Henderson says

    September 21, 2020 at 5:44 pm

    I love the new fireplace! I totally agree with your comment that the dark brown was heavy. The off white really blends well with the walls and softens the room. I guess there are those that love the natural color of the stone but your change was spot on for your style. Good job!

    Reply
  2. Edna says

    April 23, 2021 at 8:06 am

    Love it! Great job! Looks very contemporary. Inspired me to try technique on my brick fireplace. Your previous fireplace too dark, made area look like a cave. Looking forward to your new decor videos, etc.! ?

    Reply

Leave a Reply Cancel reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Primary Sidebar

Looking For Something?

CONNECT

Meet Taryn

Taryn Whiteaker

Hi and welcome! I'm Taryn and the voice of style behind Taryn Whiteaker Designs. Sharing our journey of modernizing our European style home in Dallas. Thanks for stopping by and don't forget to subscribe to my mailing list to get all the latest updates! Read more...

Footer

THIS SITE

  • Home
  • About
  • Contact
  • Partner with Taryn

Privacy Policy

If you are interested in learning more about data that might be collected by this site you are encouraged to read the Privacy Policy

COPYRIGHT POLICY

All images on this site are copyright of Design, Dining and Diapers, LLC. Unless otherwise noted. You may not use these images without written permission. If you would like to feature a project shown on Design, Dining and Diapers you may use a maximum of 2 images and include a visible link back to the project.

More From The Gram

tarynwhiteaker_designs

Taryn Whiteaker Designs
Time to clean up the pavers, get rid of the water Time to clean up the pavers, get rid of the water residue, and make them look polished and glossy again! 

Comment YES PLEASE and I’ll send you the Stone Sealer + Gloss I’m using! 

#homedecor #dallasblogger #diyhomedecor #homeprojects #diy #diyproducts #bdcbrands #partner #exterior
Comment LINKS for these new fun finds! These artif Comment LINKS for these new fun finds! These artificial bushes can be used in planters or simply in the ground. Would look so great lining a driveway! 

#amazonfinds #neutralhome #exterior_design #exterior #exteriors #homedecor #homefinds #neutralhomedecor #dallasblogger #amazonhome #diyhomedecor
Comment SHOP for all the links to last month’s t Comment SHOP for all the links to last month’s top neutral home decor favs. 

#homedecorating #homestyle #homedecorideas #decoratingdeninteriors #decor #neutralhomedecor #doingneutralright #ispyraddesign #dallasblogger
I finally found THE piece for this corner on our c I finally found THE piece for this corner on our courtyard! It’s the perfect finishing touch. This outdoor mirror is absolutely stunning and very high quality. It would work well indoors too. I just love how it reflects the rest of the courtyard and you can see every angle in it. It makes the lights sparkle at night and it’s just dreamy! 

Comment SHOP and I’ll send you a link to the mirror and my approved artificial trees! 

#neutraldecor #dallasblogger #homedecor #exteriordecor #exteriors #diy #homestyle #homedetails #decorating
Comment SHOP for my favorite wireless art lights! Comment SHOP for my favorite wireless art lights! No hard wiring required, these are luxurious and the best I have found for quality battery operated lights. I will use them again and again! 

Color: antique brushed bronze jn purple bedroom
  Gold in baseball bedroom 

#lighting #amazonfind #homedecortips #decorating #homedecorlovers #homestyle #homedesign #homefinds #amazonhome #amazonhomefinds #amazonfinds
Comment SHOP and I’ll send you the links to ever Comment SHOP and I’ll send you the links to everything! Summer capsule wardrobe ideas! Mix and match pieces for summer coastal looks or also business casual. The white dress, white sweater and blue striped shorts and seersucker top are my favorites! 

Use code HELLOSUMMER20 for GibsonLook pieces. 

#dallasblogger #summeroutfits #capsulewardrobe #summertime #summeressentials #gibsonlook #outfits #outfitideasforyou #mystyle #summerdress
Comment SHOP and I’ll send you the links to ever Comment SHOP and I’ll send you the links to everything! 

#ad We’ve been working on a few refreshes in our backyard this year! The sun has worn down a lot of our furniture out here so we are swapping out our weathered umbrella tables with these gorgeous black fluted tables from @veradek . I already had the matching planters out here (and love them BTW), and decided to add one more in the SandStone color for a bit of contrast. #myveradek #reimagineoutdoors #meetyououtside
Current snap shot of our main family room! We will Current snap shot of our main family room! We will be starting phase 1 in here later this year and I wanted to capture it as it stands now. Almost everything in here was either brought from our Washington home 3 years ago or bought second hand! Piece by piece this room has become a cozy space for our family over the last 3 years. The new stairs are staying and will work into the new design, I love them so much. 

#neutral #neutralhomeedit #homedecorating #homedesign #cozyhome #interiorideas #interiordesign #neutraldecorstyles #neutralhomedecor #dallashome
Part 1 reveal of my tween son’s bold sports bedr Part 1 reveal of my tween son’s bold sports bedroom!  It took an awhile to get the perfect purple for this look, you can swipe to see my initial fail. It was tricky. But I’m glad we kept going because the look is everything we envisioned and exactly what my son wanted. I still have lots more to do in here, it’s not even close to being finished. But I’m sure loving the dramatic before and after so far. Linking all sources. 

Comment SHOP below to receive a DM with the link to this post on my LTK ⬇ https://liketk.it/5dqhy #ltkhome #ltkfamily #ltkkids #boysbedroom #boysroom #kidsbedroom #kidsroom #potterybarnteen #lovemypbteen #football #sportsroom
Follow on Instagram

Copyright© 2025 · Brunch Pro Theme by Shay Bocks · Hosting by 3116 Digital